The Fate of Manyholes.com Is In Your Hands

I need your suggestion.

I am relaunching my site, Manyholes.com and I paid $$ for designers to create logo for me. I received more than 100+ entries, I shortlisted 3 of them (took me long long time), and now I have to decide ONE winner. I had fun picking on lousy designers, it’s like a bad boss with bad attitude. Hehehe.

The process was fun. A bit sad that the competition was over. Now is the time to pick that ONE SINGLE winner, and honestly I am having hard time -__- it is like a single guy who can’t decide which girl to chase because all has their merits.

Here are the 3 designs I shortlisted.

Entry (A)

Entry (B)

Entry (C)

The logos are judged based on following criteria:

  1. First-impression
  2. Attractive
  3. Easy to read
  4. Long lasting (won’t bored easily)
  5. Most importantly, you like it!

Personally, I like Entry A the most. But Entry B and Entry C seems to give longer lasting impression, and can use the logo for many years to come. Not surprisingly, Entry (B) and Entry (C) are created by same designer.

To put in an analogy, Entry (A) is the hot chick in club. You want her tonight and you want her badly. While Entry (B) and Entry (C) are the wife material. You can look at her for many years also not sian wan.

I need to make decision by Wednesday (2 June 2010).

I need your suggestions.

Please drop your comment.. short answer will do. Even more awesome if you can explain your reason :)

Related Posts with ThumbnailsShare
Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

New logo is online! :)

http://www.manyholes.com

I asked the designer to put smiley face into B... that should solve the problem :)

Thanks for the opinion everyone. The new logo will be online tonight. Wohooo!

I like the design A. there is something interesting and eye catching. and not boring. cool and beautiful

entry C!
i want the smiley face :)

Darn it. I mean entry B

Each design has its own distinctions. I'll roll a dice maybe.

A and B.

As you said, A is more suitable based on your content. B is more "formal". But ultimately I will go for A.

人生有多少個十年?!就活得瘋狂吧!!敢敢來!!
.-= BooNMiNG´s last blog ..Movie Review: *I PUNCHED SHREK* =-.

I think Entry C will be perfect. It's simple and uncluttered - just like the website.

Results so far (online and offline)

Entry A: 2 votes
Entry B: 1 vote
Entry C: 2 votes

A. It brings out the fun n engaging side of the site. Unless tat's not the way you intended? =)

I vote for A. It just grabs my attention every time.
I think C and be improved, the font design makes 'a' and 'e' rather illegible.

b with the smiley in c.
simplicity is good. :)

Bing, I like B or C. B is nice but simple. C is cute cuz got smiley!
hehe. I will choose a more stable wife. hehe!